
Several
Several Theorists
Several theorists offer their theories.
*This summary was verified by Verified by each of the authors on November 15, 2026.
Dualism Additional Theories
Kamen's Human Soul as a Quantum Field
Theoretical engineer Edward Kamen proposes that “the human soul is a type of quantum field,” which interacts with only certain fields in the physical universe and not directly with matter. The claim is made that “fields that interact with the soul field include electromagnetic waves,” citing as evidence “near-death experiences where events that could not have been seen through the eyes of the individual are verified" (Kamen & Kamen, 2023). In other words, "the human soul is a manifestation of a soul field consisting of a collection of quantum-like fields. The soul field interacts with the electromagnetic field, manifested by photons interacting with the quanta of the soul field" (Kamen and Kamen, 2025).
Extending the theory, Kamen speculates that because “electric fields and electromagnetic fields have the same quanta consisting of photons, electric fields may also interact with the soul field.” This could result in the transfer of information, he says, from working memory to the soul through electric fields produced by neural ensembles in the human brain. Further, the soul field may also affect neurons on the molecular level, perhaps via electric fields and cytoelectric coupling (Kamen & Kamen, 2023). "The human soul is coupled to the body through its interactions with bioelectric fields in the body. Manifestations of the quantum-like fields comprising the soul field may carry out different functions such as encoding memories and experiences, representing emotion states, and defining personal identity. Interactions of these fields and their quanta could produce emergent properties such as self-awareness and consciousness" (Kamen and Kamen, 2025).
Parikh’s Awareness-Field Interaction Theory
Materials scientist Suketu Arun Parikh proposes Awareness-Field Interaction Theory (AFIT) in which phenomenal consciousness arises from a coupling interaction between integrated neural information and a fundamental, non-local awareness field—a basic property of reality irreducible to matter—such that experience is neither generated by neural activity alone nor identical to it, but is the product of their causal interaction (Parikh, 2026).
AFIT reframes the hard problem of consciousness (Chalmers, 1995) from a question of emergence to one of interaction. Where Integrated Information Theory (IIT) identifies phenomenal consciousness with integrated information Φ by brute identity (Tononi, 2004), AFIT holds that Φ is the physical coupling condition—the key that unlocks interaction with the awareness field—rather than consciousness itself. This preserves IIT's central empirical insight while supplying an ontological account IIT cannot provide: why Φ should be accompanied by experience at all.
AFIT's coupling mechanism is located, following Penrose and Hameroff (1996), at neuronal microtubules, where quantum-coherent states in tubulin proteins undergo orchestrated objective reduction (Orch OR). AFIT reinterprets this event: rather than generating proto-experience directly, the OR event is the physical gate through which globally integrated neural activity couples with the awareness field. According to Parikh, this accounts for the striking empirical finding that chemically diverse anesthetic agents—halothane, xenon, propofol—suppress consciousness by binding hydrophobic pockets in tubulin, selectively disabling the coupling mechanism while leaving cortical activity intact (Hameroff, 2006).
AFIT's distinguishing contribution beyond existing dualisms and field theories is a second, dynamic coupling variable. Coupling strength at any moment depends not only on an organism's neural integration capacity (Φ max, set by species architecture, from fungi through humans) but on the quality of mental activity within that architecture (q(t)), which varies moment-to-moment within a single nervous system. Ordinary waking consciousness is characteristically divided—organized around competing, ego-driven content—and the phenomenological path from inattentive waking through witness-consciousness to the state classical Vedantic sources term Turiya (Nikhilananda, 1949) reflects the progressive resolution of this division as q(t) approaches its ceiling, not any change in underlying neural capacity. Functional form C(t) ≈ Φ_max × q(t).
In later work, Parikh resolves q(t) into three nested disturbances acting on different timescales: long-term saṃskāra (accumulated impressions), mood (the mental state over hours to days), and present reaction, so that q(t) ≈ (1 − L)(1 − M)(1 − R). When all three are clear, awareness meets experience directly. The terms are nested: reactions accumulate into mood, and moods into saṃskāra. Development reverses this. It is understood as clearing rather than attainment, culminating in natural awareness and the dissolution of the sense of a doer (Parikh, 2026b).
AFIT's empirical signature is the 200–500 ms latency between stimulus and conscious registration (Libet et al., 1979), which Parikh reinterprets as the time taken by memory, emotional classification, and self-reference to intercept the stimulus before awareness meets it. The gap never reaches zero; what development reduces is its interception component. Because latency paradigms require a task, they lose validity in choiceless awareness. There, AFIT proposes a complementary index: a shift in resting EEG from beta toward alpha and theta rhythms.
AFIT also offers an account of karma as recording within the gap. Reactions that run ahead of awareness are reinforced as conditioning, so the gap sustains itself; where awareness is present throughout, nothing is recorded (cf. Krishnamurti, 1954). As an explicitly speculative extension, the mental state may leave a non-material impression on localized awareness, corresponding to the traditional notions of vāsanā and the individual ātman.
Ultimately, according to Parikh, AFIT provides a rigorous scientific grounding for Eastern philosophical concepts of pure consciousness, Brahman, and Atman. By demonstrating how the fundamental awareness field is constrained by an individual's own mental activity—originating from ego, desire, and bias—AFIT bridges ancient metaphysics and the study of deep meditative states with the biophysics of quantum coherence and the information-theoretic framework of IIT, offering profound implications for understanding and enhancing human experience.
References
Chalmers, D.J. (1995). Facing up to the problem of consciousness. Journal of Consciousness Studies, 2(3), 200–219.
Hameroff, S.R. (2006). The entwined mysteries of anesthesia and consciousness. Anesthesiology, 105(2), 400–412.
Nikhilananda, S. (trans.) (1949). The Mandukya Upanishad with Gaudapada's Karika. New York: Ramakrishna-Vivekananda Center.
Krishnamurti, J. (1954). The First and Last Freedom. London: Victor Gollancz.
Libet, B., Wright, E.W., Feinstein, B. and Pearl, D.K. (1979). Subjective referral of the timing for a conscious sensory experience. Brain, 102(1), 193–224.
Parikh, S.A. (2026) The temporal signature of the divided mind: Awareness-Field Interaction Theory and the spectrum from ordinary waking consciousness to pure awareness. Manuscript under review.
Penrose, R. and Hameroff, S.R. (1996). Orchestrated reduction of quantum coherence in brain microtubules: A model for consciousness. Mathematics and Computers in Simulation, 40(3–4), 453–480.
Tononi, G. (2004). An information integration theory of consciousness. BMC Neuroscience, 5, 42.
Saktyartoro’s Semantic Causality Framework
Independent researcher Jatmiko Saktyartoro’s Semantic Causality Framework (SCF) proposes that consciousness cannot be wholly physical, because at least one of its operations, choosing on the basis of understood meaning, appears to escape deterministic physical causation.
The framework’s starting image is a traffic light turning green: dozens of cars begin to move, while a bird perched on the pole stays still. The difference, Saktyartoro argues, is meaning. The drivers understood the signal; the bird did not. Meaning itself, independent of physical force, can therefore act as a cause, a process he calls Semantic Causality (SCa) (Saktyartoro, 2025).
The argument rests on two proposed experiments, the Semantic Causality Experiment (SCE) and the Non-Random Non-Deterministic Semantic Causality Experiment (NRNDSCE). Saktyartoro describes both as falsifiable and feasible with modest means. Neither has been performed; for now, both function as thought experiments. If they were carried out as designed and yielded the predicted results, he claims, they would show that understanding alone can influence behavior and break deterministic chains of cause and effect.
Within this semantic mode, causes can arise that are neither random nor determined by prior physical states: Non-Random Non-Deterministic Semantic Causes (NRNDSCs). Such causes are intentional yet not fixed by antecedent physical conditions. Saktyartoro therefore infers that they operate outside physical causality, and he treats them as functionally equivalent to genuine free will.
The step from free will to consciousness is explicit. Consciousness need not always involve free will, since an entity could be aware without willing anything, and there may be more than one kind of free will. But at least one form operates within consciousness and requires awareness of options before choice. If that form of free will lies outside physical causality yet inside consciousness, then consciousness itself cannot be entirely physical.
One consequence concerns artificial intelligence. Any system confined to deterministic or stochastic physical processes, including all forms of AI, could not generate non-random, non-deterministic semantic causes. It therefore could not possess genuine free will or the form of consciousness that enables it.
In sum, the SCF holds that materialism and physical determinism cannot account for the full scope of causation. Reality may comprise not only physical dimensions but also a semantic domain, and perhaps others. Saktyartoro suggests these domains work together in shaping the structure of existence.
Reference
Saktyartoro, J. (2025). The Tale of the Traffic Light: A Reflection Toward the Possible Existence of Objective Free Will. Preprint. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17568280
Staub's Consciousness and Biological Evolution
Independent researcher John Staub claims consciousness resulted after a half-billion-year process of vertebrate evolution. Fish brains run on full automatic. Birds use maternal love, pre-wired in the brain, to help their vulnerable eggs survive. Although mammals can be self-aware and might feel something like guilt, they lack any sense of morality. Only humans have gained both consciousness and that essential ingredient called free will (Staub, 2025).
Is self-awareness merely an illusion that helps mammals survive? Staub says yes. But is consciousness also an illusion? Here, he says no. “Consciousness is more than a survival mechanism.” To him, the key to understanding consciousness is free will. He suggests an unknown force or energy, working at the quantum level within brain neurons, directs electron movement. But if this energy is undirected, you’re back to square one, no free will. “What directs this force or energy?” For lack of a better word, he calls it “God” and calls this dualistic alliance of God and brain “consciousness.”
A reasonable question: If God is running the show, why aren’t all decisions perfect? Staub’s answer: “God’s abilities are limited. Only a tiny fraction of God’s imperfect essence resides within everyone’s brain, with each person’s consciousness, unique.”
Staub argues a person can believe both free will and God exist, or neither. “The laws of physics won’t let you pick and choose.” Prove free will is impossible, and life will become meaningless, with society quickly devolving into nihilism.
Motivation becomes crucial. “Why would a God give humans consciousness? And why did it take 14 billion years to create a human?” To Staub, the answer seems obvious. “God is not omnipotent, is not physical, and is extremely limited in our physical universe.” He wrote these words fifty years ago: “We are the eyes, the ears, and hands of God, and in return, we are given the sense of beauty, of music, and of love.”