Home / Panpsychisms / Tye’s Irreducible Consciousness*

Tye’s Irreducible Consciousness*

Tye argues that phenomenal consciousness admits no borderline cases, while every physical or functional candidate for it is vague; consciousness therefore cannot be reduced, and its brute emergence is incredible. He resolves the paradox with consciousness*, a sharp, contentless, irreducible feature present at the bedrock of reality, transferred to complex states that occupy a global workspace. What each experience is like is fixed by what it represents, as in his PANIC theory. Tye claims this dissolves the combination problem without making rocks conscious; critics question the sharpness and intelligibility of transfer.

VerifiedVerified*
Photo of Michael Tye

Michael Tye

Philosopher

Michael Tye (b. 1950) is a British philosopher and Dallas TACA Centennial Professor in Liberal Arts at the University of Texas at Austin, where he has taught since 2003. He studied physics and philosophy at Oxford, earned his PhD at the State University of New York, and taught at Haverford College and Temple University, with a decade of visiting appointments at King’s College London and a brief chair at St Andrews. His books include Ten Problems of Consciousness (1995), Consciousness Revisited (2009), and Vagueness and the Evolution of Consciousness (2021).

*This summary was verified by Michael Tye on May 28, 2025.

Landscape

Key Takeaways

  • Core Claim

    Phenomenal consciousness is irreducible and exists as fundamental “consciousness*” or protoconsciousness.

  • How It Works

    Consciousness resides in basic entities and transfers to complex systems meeting specific functional and representational conditions.

  • Distinguishing Idea

    Retains representationalism but solves panpsychism’s combination problem by making consciousness strictly on/off.

Tye’s Irreducible Consciousness*

Philosopher Michael Tye, long a leading reductive representationalist, has switched sides, as it were, and now defends a nuanced panpsychist representationalism grounded in a single observation: phenomenal consciousness admits no borderline cases, whereas every plausible physical or functional candidate for it is vague (Tye, 2021, 2024a). From this he infers that consciousness cannot be reduced, and, finding brute emergence of something sharp from vague physical goings-on incredible, he locates at the bedrock of reality an irreducible, sharp, contentless feature he calls consciousness*. Consciousness* is transferred from micro-entities to complex states that satisfy a functional condition, specified as occupancy of a global workspace, and the specific character of each experience is fixed by what it represents, as in his earlier PANIC theory.[1] The result, Tye argues, dissolves the combination problem, avoids attributing consciousness to rocks and tables, and preserves both the insights of reductive theories and the reality of the hard problem.

From Reductive Physicalism to Irreducibility

Tye’s conversion is the more striking for the position it abandons. His PANIC theory was among the most influential reductive accounts of phenomenal consciousness, and his contingentist defense of physicalism, Tye’s Contingentism, was written as the physicalist’s best hope, though by then he no longer held that every element of consciousness is captured by higher-level reductions (Tye, 2024b). He now holds that there are no borderline cases of phenomenal consciousness itself: it is an on/off matter. As a result, in part, he explains, “I don’t see any plausible (non-arbitrary) reductive physical candidates for consciousness, so understood. So, while I did elaborate a contingent version of reductive physicalism earlier, I no longer see the need to do so” (Tye, 2025). Rather, he asserts boldly, “The best explanation for the absence of borderline cases with respect to phenomenal consciousness is that phenomenal consciousness is irreducible” (Tye, 2024a, 2025).

Tye reflects humorously on his conversion, a worldview transformation that must have surprised, perhaps shocked, colleagues: “So how, on Earth, did I become a panpsychist? Well, you may perhaps have heard the comment made by John Perry, the Stanford philosopher, that if you study consciousness long enough you either become a panpsychist or you go into administration! I haven’t gone into administration; so, I’ve become a panpsychist. I have to say that this conversion bothered me for quite a while but then I stopped worrying and came to love the view” (Tye, 2024a). The rest of his argument explains how he arrived there and how the new position relates to the old.

The Sharpness of Consciousness

Tye’s starting point is that being phenomenally conscious, unlike being tall, rich, or alive, has no borderline instances. Cases that seem to be counterexamples locate the indeterminacy in what is experienced rather than in whether experience is present: a patient at the dentist may be unsure whether a sensation is pain or pressure, and a pain fading under morphine may pass through states hard to classify, but feeling continues throughout. Even straining to detect a faint tone does not yield an intermediate case, since failing to hear a sound is hearing silence, an experience of absence that Tye supports with recent evidence that silences produce the same duration illusions as sounds (Goh, Phillips, and Firestone, 2023). Experiences differ greatly in richness, from a richly detailed visual scene to an experience of darkness, but one state cannot be more an experience than another (Tye, 2024a).

Tye argues that this sharpness is known a priori, as we know that a surface cannot be red and green all over, and he rejects three escape routes. The concept might pick out a vague natural kind of which we have an inaccurate conception; but we cannot even imagine a borderline case, as we can imagine gold that is not really yellow. The concept might be empty, like phlogiston; but that is eliminativism. The concept might evolve into a vague functional one; but it would then be a concept of something other than consciousness (Tye, 2024a). The position is shared by Simon (2017) and opposed by Papineau (2002).

From Sharpness to Paradox

If consciousness is sharp, it cannot be identical with anything physical, because all physical candidates admit borderline cases. Crick and Koch’s Neural Correlates of Consciousness, read in part as identifying consciousness with oscillations near 40 Hz, illustrates the point: endlessly many equally eligible precise frequencies compete for identification, so either all are consciousness, which is impossible, or none is. The argument follows Benacerraf’s case against identifying numbers with sets and Lewis’s problem of the many (Tye, 2024a). Yet if consciousness is non-physical, it must have emerged during evolution through brute laws, something radically new and sharp appearing from vague physical processes without explanation. Tye finds this hard to believe, so sharpness, irreducibility, and the rejection of brute emergence cannot all be held together: a paradox (Tye, 2021, 2024a).

Consciousness* at the Bedrock

Tye’s resolution is that consciousness neither emerged nor reduces: it was present at the foundations all along. At the fundamental level, however, what exists is not consciousness proper but consciousness*, which others would call protoconsciousness: a feature that admits of no further species and is irreducible (Tye, 2024a). Borrowing Fodor’s device, Tye compares it to belief* and desire*: just as a belief is a state that is a belief* and has representational content, a conscious state is a state that is conscious* and has representational content. Consciousness* is what is distinctive of conscious states, but it is not sufficient for them. Because consciousness* is contentless and has no kinds, it is sharp; the vagueness found in experience belongs entirely to what experiences represent.

Tye summarizes the mechanism and its consequence for vagueness in his own words: In Tye’s current view, at the most fundamental level, there is what Tye labels ‘consciousness*,’ which others would call ‘protoconsciousness.’ This is irreducible, he stresses. What happens as systems become more complex, he explains, is that “consciousness* gets transferred from the fundamental entities to complex combinations of them that meet certain further conditions, specifically combinations that play the right functional role and that represent various properties and property complexes. Those combinations are conscious, in the full-blooded sense. It is really consciousness* that is on/off, since experiences can have borderline cases with what they represent (e.g., am I now experiencing pure red or is there a hint of orange in it?)” (Tye, 2024a, 2025). Papineau (2022) reads consciousness* as belonging to the categorical basis of physical simples, and Tye accordingly denies that the view amounts to anti-physicalism (Tye, 2021).

Panpsychist Representationalism and the Combination Problem

The combination problem asks how micro-experiences, which are not experiences of red, could compose an experience of red that seems phenomenally simple. His version of panpsychism, he says, “explains differences in the phenomenal character of experiences via differences in what the experiences represent,” and so provides a straightforward and satisfying solution to the problem (Tye, 2024a). This aspect of the view, Tye stresses, is compatible with the representationalist claims he made in the past. In a way, he reflects, “what I have now is my original PANIC theory with the addition of consciousness*” (Tye, 2025); see Tye’s PANIC Representationalism. The solution works by dividing the labor. Specific phenomenal character comes from representation: the experience of red is a conscious* state that represents red, the experience of a loud noise a conscious* state that represents a loud noise, and introspection, by the transparency thesis, reveals only represented properties (Tye, 2024a). What must be explained is only how consciousness* reaches complex states. Here Tye invokes Baars’s and Dehaene’s Global Workspace Theory, read not as an account of the nature of consciousness, which would make consciousness vague, but as specifying the condition under which consciousness* is transferred from micro-parts to wholes. The model is an ensemble of graceful dancers, whose arrangement may or may not make the whole graceful; once the workspace condition is definitely met, the state is conscious, period.

This version rejects universalist panpsychism: rocks and states such as weighing fifty pounds are not conscious. Tye also argues that Integrated Information Theory, taken reductively, faces a dilemma: identifying consciousness with any integrated information above zero makes thermometers conscious, while requiring a sufficient amount makes consciousness vague (Tye, 2024a).

Speculative Applications

Tye adds two proposals he marks as speculative. If consciousness is an on/off phenomenon, an on/off switch in the brain becomes plausible, and he considers Crick and Koch’s suggestion that the claustrum integrates conscious perception. Electrical stimulation at an electrode between the left claustrum and anterior insula in one epilepsy patient repeatedly and reversibly abolished consciousness (Koubeissi et al., 2014), yet a patient of Damasio’s without a functional claustrum remains conscious. Tye reconciles the cases by treating the claustrum as nature’s ignition key for filling the workspace, with brainstem activity driving prefrontal cortex via the thalamus as an alternative route, like hotwiring a car. He also suggests that the Tibetan Buddhist postmortem meditative state of thukdam might involve global workspace states whose contents are progressively stripped to representations of total absence, while conceding that he has no account of how such states could preserve the body (Tye, 2024a).

Critical Reception

Papineau (2022) argues that the transfer condition reintroduces the arbitrariness Tye charges against physicalism, since whether an arrangement is poised or occupies a workspace is itself vague, and that Tye could instead identify consciousness with poised representation and accept its vagueness. Mendelovici and Bourget (2023) contend that consciousness* in nonfundamental entities inherits the vagueness of the transfer condition and so is not sharp, that the transfer itself remains unintelligible, and that a borderline pain still has a fully determinate way it feels, a sharp phenomenal property the view cannot accommodate. Because consciousness* is not itself consciousness, the position also bears comparison with Panprotopsychism, although Tye presents it as a form of panpsychism.

Footnote

  1. Tye’s PANIC theory of consciousness is a representationalist theory. “PANIC” is an acronym that stands for Poised, Abstract, Nonconceptual, Intentional Content.

References

Goh, R. Z., Phillips, I., and Firestone, C. (2023). The perception of silence. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 120.

Koubeissi, M. Z., Bartolomei, F., Beltagy, A., and Picard, F. (2014). Electrical stimulation of a small brain area reversibly disrupts consciousness. Epilepsy & Behavior, 37, 32–35. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.yebeh.2014.05.027

Mendelovici, A., and Bourget, D. (2023). Review of Michael Tye, Vagueness and the Evolution of Consciousness. Philosophical Review, 132(2), 338–343.

Papineau, D. (2002). Thinking about Consciousness. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Papineau, D. (2022). Review of Michael Tye, Vagueness and the Evolution of Consciousness: Through the Looking Glass. Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews, July 6, 2022.

Simon, J. (2017). Vagueness and zombies: Why ‘phenomenally conscious’ has no borderline cases. Philosophical Studies, 174, 2105–2123.

Tye, M. (2021). Vagueness and the Evolution of Consciousness: Through the Looking Glass. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Tye, M. (2024a). How I learned to stop worrying and love panpsychism. Journal of Consciousness Studies, 31(9–10), 10–28. https://doi.org/10.53765/20512201.31.9.010

Tye, M. (2024b). A new solution to the hard problem of consciousness. In A. Grzankowski and A. Savile (Eds.), Thought: Its Origin and Reach: Essays for Mark Sainsbury. London: Routledge.

Tye, M. (2025). Personal communication.

Tools

Share
El quote rightCite
Download PDF

Categories



References

Tye, 2024Michael Tye
How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love Panpsychism
Journal of Consciousness Studies, 31, No. 9–10, 2024, pp. 10–28. DOI: 10.53765/20512201.31.9.010:
https://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/imp/jcs/2024/00000031/f0020009/art00002
Tye, 2025Michael Tye
Personal communication

Footnotes

1.

Tye’s PANIC theory of consciousness is a representationalist theory. “PANIC” is an acronym that stands for Poised, Abstract, Nonconceptual, Intentional Content.

References

Tye, 2025
Michael Tye
Personal communication
2025

Tye, 2024
Michael Tye
How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love Panpsychism
2024
Journal of Consciousness Studies, 31, No. 9–10, 2024, pp. 10–28. DOI: 10.53765/20512201.31.9.010:
Google Scholar