Idealism Additional Theories
As creator and host of Closer To Truth, Robert Lawrence Kuhn receives ideas from viewers globally. These unsolicited papers are often elaborate treatises, the majority of which focus on consciousness or cosmology. He says he looks at all of them, keeps an open mind (with at least one eye squinty skeptical), learns some, and responds as he can. Here are some of them.

Several
Several Theorists
Several theorists offer their theories.
*This summary was verified by Robert Lawrence Kuhn.
Idealism Additional Theories
As creator and host of Closer To Truth, I [RLK] receive ideas from viewers globally. These unsolicited papers are often elaborate treatises, the majority of which focus on consciousness or cosmology. I look at all of them, keep an open mind (with at least one eye squinty skeptical), learn some, respond as I can. I marvel at the passion and respect the dedication.[1]
Addressing the “ultimate questions” of cosmic existence and human sentience is the highest calling of human beings, which is why I appreciate diverse ideas (Kuhn, 2023). While I cannot agree with many of the assumptions, and certainly not with most of the assertions, I see the scope of subjects as exemplifying the kinds of issues and challenges that enliven the human spirit (small “s”).
To conclude this section on Idealism, I note several models of idealism I've received (among many). The only judgment I pass is that consciousness in general, and idealism in particular, fire the imagination as well as stir the passions.
Paddock & Buervenich's Flip-Book Idealism
Flip-Book Idealism (FBI), developed by neuroscientist Silvia Paddock and physicist Thomas Buervenich, agrees with other forms of idealism that spacetime is not primary and that consciousness exists outside of it. According to FBI, observer/participants, who are individuations of this consciousness, detect patterns in a facet of consciousness called the “Urgrund”—the fundamental essence of existence—and shape this information into frames of experience by translating complex signal patterns into qualia.
One hallmark of FBI is that the generation of experiential frames by consciousness creates the arrow of time. Its observer-based viewpoint of reality aligns with quantum mechanics, such that wave-particle duality and entanglement (“spooky action at a distance”) are no longer odd or mysterious. FBI distinguishes itself from other forms of idealism by asserting that conscious agents primarily interact with one another through the intermediary of the Urgrund in a kind of question-and-answer game and by proposing that spacetime is a set of rules that consciousness needs to adhere to when creating experiential frames to allow for the experienced world to be consistent. FBI does not solve the hard problem of consciousness but attests to its significance (Paddock & Buervenich, 2023).
According to reviewer Jo Edwards, “The central idea is that our subjectivity is the inherently conscious universe enjoying local snapshots in discrete time ‘frames’, set by brain interactions, that are elided into a sense of movement and continuity, as for a cartoon flipbook.” He concludes that the authors make “a nice case for these being fundamental time units that in the brain are a few milliseconds long but elsewhere will follow rules of quantum field theory—perhaps as decoherence intervals. I think this is the right direction to go in. It is nice to see mainstream quantum theory rather than fringe interpretations or invocations of entanglement, tachyons, or dark matter. Like genes, consciousness is likely to be based on kitchen sink biophysics” (Edwards, 2024).
Duan's Platonic Computation
Materials scientist turned consciousness researcher Simon Duan proposes that “metaconsciousness” (the power to conceive, perceive, and be self-aware) is the formless, contentless, infinite potentiality and thus is the most fundamental and irreducible existence. Creation of all else is rendered by the “Platonic computer” that exists in the realm of Forms, and which is made by, of, with, and from metaconsciousness. “Platonic computation” models how metaconsciousness generates the perceived actualities, including abstract entities as well as all physical and nonphysical realities. It is postulated that this is achieved via digital computation using the Platonic computer. The hypothesis of “Platonic computation” offers a solution to the inverse hard problem of consciousness: how matter arises out of consciousness (Duan, 2022; Duan, 2024).
Jaffe’s Cognitive Dream Interface Theory
Dermatologist/Mohs surgeon Andrew Jaffe proposes Cognitive Dream Interface Theory (CDIT) as an idealist theory of phenomenal consciousness, positing that one fundamental awareness is experienced through localized individual perspectives within a shared, lawfully constrained world. Its distinctive starting point is ordinary dreaming. Dreams are treated not merely as metaphor but as a familiar demonstration that awareness can experience a complete world containing apparent space, time, bodies, memory, causality, other individuals, and an autobiographical self without being identical to any of them. CDIT asks whether waking reality could represent a vastly more stable, constrained, and intersubjectively shared expression of this same capacity (LaBerge, 1985; Voss et al., 2009).
CDIT reverses the explanatory direction of physicalism. Rather than beginning with matter and asking how subjective experience emerges from physical processes, it begins with awareness, the one phenomenon known directly, as a natural primitive from which experience arises. Neuroscience, evolution, and physics retain their explanatory roles, but describe the organization and regularities of the shared interface rather than the origin of awareness itself. The brain is part of the experienced structure through which awareness becomes localized as a particular perspective.
Localization also addresses why experience occurs as this individual rather than another. No preexisting self requires assignment to a particular body. Each conscious organism is a localized window of the same fundamental awareness, and from within each window that perspective necessarily appears as “me.” Localization precedes autobiography: infants experience before developing a stable autobiographical identity, while dreams show that identity, memory, and biography can change without eliminating first-person experience.
CDIT differs from panpsychism because matter does not contain separate units of consciousness; from solipsism because waking reality is shared across perspectives; and from dissociation-based idealism because individuality arises through localization rather than fragmentation of a cosmic mind. Waking life differs from ordinary dreaming through its extraordinary constraint, continuity, mathematical regularity, and intersubjective agreement.
Dreaming makes CDIT’s central proposal directly familiar. Every night awareness can experience another identity, different memories and relationships, and an apparently external world that seems real while the dream lasts. Upon awakening, the temporary autobiography largely disappears while awareness remains. CDIT proposes the same basic architecture for waking life on a far more stable and shared scale: awareness is fundamental, conscious selves are its localized perspectives, and the physical world is the highly constrained experiential reality they share. Dreams therefore provide a first-person example of the relationship between awareness, identity, and experienced reality that CDIT proposes as fundamental.
References
Jaffe, A. T. (2026). Living the Dream: Cognitive Dream Interface Theory (CDIT), A Philosophical and Scientific Inquiry into Consciousness and Reality. Essentia. Forthcoming September 1, 2026.
LaBerge, S. (1985). Lucid Dreaming: The Power of Being Awake and Aware in Your Dreams. Jeremy P. Tarcher.
Voss, U., Holzmann, R., Tuin, I., & Hobson, J. A. (2009). Lucid dreaming: A state of consciousness with features of both waking and non-lucid dreaming. Sleep, 32(9), 1191–1200.
Rodriguez's C-Pattern Theory
Neuroscientist Pablo Rodriguez posits that the brain can generate only c-patterns, no experiences, because experiences are qualitatively different from matter. Experiences are thus regarded as created by the universe, in that c-patterns are constantly “read” and converted to experiences. C-Pattern Theory has three basic points.
First, the brain doesn't generate conscious experiences; it generates c-patterns, which are complex geometric three-dimensional structures composed of all action potentials from all of the brain's [relevant] neurons firing at any given moment. The c-pattern's specific form and geometry are postulated as being what fully defines any conscious experience. So, for every moment, there's a different c-pattern and a corresponding experience defined by it.
Second, an experience is defined by a c-pattern's form, but each is created by the universe, not by the brain; rather, a c-pattern's specific form and geometry encodes an experience as a discrete expression of a universal geometric experience language, which the universe understands perfectly and decodes into real, actual experiences.
Third, we are not body and brain; we are consciousness. If c-patterns are mere symbols converted to experiences, then only consciousness can be what's having all experiences. And as we are the ones experiencing, we are parts of consciousness. Different organisms have different c-patterns, experiences, and levels of understanding reality. So, this world is just what our c-patterns currently allow until we manage to expand them to the next level. Thus, true human progress is possible only if the experience language is deciphered and c-patterns are expanded towards greater understanding (Rodriguez, 2023).
Koyoti's Is-Ness
Engineer and spiritual journeyist Michael Koyoti states that “all consciousness is one.” Every human spirit is unique, with our singular thoughts, perceptions, and experiences, like a whirlpool in an infinite ocean of consciousness. While universal consciousness is infinite in space and time, each conscious being experiences creation from a unique perspective. The power of spirit does not come from its past achievements or future aspirations but from its existence in the present instant. This is the essence of our existence. Awareness of this essence is the state of “Is-Ness” (Koyoti, 2023).
Marr's Source Division Theory
Independent philosopher Gary Justin Marr's Source Division Theory is an idealist cosmology holding that phenomenal consciousness is fundamental. A single aware Source, undiminished by expression, differentiates itself into bounded centers of experience not by severance but by "begetting," and each center is consciousness localized through a body, or "vessel," rather than produced by it (Marr, 2026). Time, physical law, and embodiment belong to the differentiated order, which Marr calls the "instrument"; death closes the bounded perspective and, in the current draft, releases the consciousness it localized. The theory stakes itself on a stated falsifier: if death is annihilation, it is wrong.
The central contrast is with analytic idealism, in which individual minds are dissociated boundaries of a universal mind-at-large (Kastrup, 2019). For Marr, finite minds ("sub-sources") are generated, not partitioned, by an act of will in which "the willing is the cut": the first act of will and the first division are one event, so asking what preceded division confuses explanatory with temporal priority. The stated motive is sharing—Source lends experience and experiences life through divided observers—from which Marr derives genuine, if grounded, local agency, since real sharing requires real others.
On the hard problem (Chalmers, 1995), the theory offers neither reduction nor emergence. Phenomenal awareness is posited at the ground; what the vessel contributes is boundedness, which Marr treats as the condition of determinate experience, since an unlimited point of view would encounter no particular place, danger, or decision. A generated perspective, he argues, inherits the aware nature of its generator, whereas a partitioned one merely suffers its boundary. Temporal order is likewise located within lived experience rather than in a clock external to Source.
Death runs on two tracks: the energy lent to the vessel returns to Source, while the consciousness itself, which Marr identifies with the soul, continues "unbound" rather than relocated. The submitted draft adopted personal continuation, superseding an earlier commitment to minimal return; the author has since revised the manuscript to present personal continuation explicitly as a hypothesis under examination, with minimal return as the formal core. The
mechanism that would preserve memory and identity without the vessel
remains marked unsolved.
Marr pairs the system with explicit methodological commitments: the falsifier, which he concedes no living observer can witness; an "honesty principle" requiring that the system be able to state its own negation; and a research program in which instruments may probe the differentiated order but never the undivided Source, with null results counting. Verification is first-personal by design. The formal statement lists its central burdens as open, including why the ground must be aware rather than impersonal, what ordering relation constitutes time, and how natural suffering is reconciled with the sharing motive.
As noted, Marr identifies annihilation at death as a condition that would contradict the theory. This specifies a potential metaphysical disconfirmation, but, he says, it cannot be witnessed by any living observer. He also requires openness to doubt and proposes investigating temporal structure and correlates of differentiation, with null results counting against specified hypotheses. The framework remains a speculative metaphysical account: begetting requires further explanation, first-person reflection does not independently establish cosmic unity, distinctive measurable predictions remain undeveloped, and the falsifier tests the survival claim, not the idealist core about phenomenal consciousness.
References
Chalmers, D. J. (1995). Facing up to the problem of consciousness. Journal of Consciousness Studies, 2(3), 200–219.
Kastrup, B. (2019). The Idea of the World: A Multi-Disciplinary Argument for the Mental Nature of Reality. Winchester, UK: Iff Books.
Marr, G. J. (2026). Source Division Theory: A Formal Statement of Unity, Differentiation, Lived Time, Shared Will, and Return (Draft v9). Unpublished manuscript.
Daw's Universal Consciousness Framework: One Undivided Ground, Undergone at Living Loops
Steven Daw’s Universal Consciousness Framework (UCF) holds that phenomenal consciousness is a single, undivided, timeless consciousness (UC) undergone wherever a self-producing, self-maintaining living loop faces the world, each such “facing” restricted by a veil to its own portion of measurable content (Daw, 2026). The ground enters no equation; UCF instead asks what physics must be like if the ground remains undivided, and offers a graded, conditional reconstruction of physical theory together with registered predictions on both the consciousness and the cosmological sides. Developed by an independent researcher with three frontier AI systems as disclosed collaborators, it is presented as an inference to the best explanation, not a measured result.
UCF starts from one fact taken as certain: subjective experience exists now. Physics describes relations, relations require relata, and the only relatum whose intrinsic nature is known from within is experience. Everything measurable (“CONTENT”) is therefore grounded in UC without being UC, and the ground performs only three roles: it makes content actual, constitutes its intrinsic nature, and locates where it is undergone. A facing occurs at a living loop that builds and repairs itself from within and holds a set point of its own; one loop, one facing. Experience is not its contents, forms one organized state rather than a stack, and runs in dependence from distinction through feeling to thought; its minimal content is a difference that matters to the loop’s own upkeep, so valence is primary. Brains regulate access, acting as shutters rather than sources, in the filter lineage of James, Broad, and Huxley. Present-day AI does not qualify as a facing, although a genuinely self-producing artificial system would, whatever its substrate.
Against panpsychism, nothing combines: experience occurs only at facings, and the ground was never divided. Against Kastrup’s analytic idealism, UC does not dissociate but is wholly present behind every facing, with only access restricted, by a veil adopted as an explicit premise rather than derived. Against Hoffman’s conscious agents, there is one ground rather than many agents. The nearest published relative is biological idealism, which likewise pairs an experiential ground with autopoietic life (Bekkers and Ciaunica, 2026).
The physics tier, which the author states can fail without refuting the core hypothesis, assembles imported theorems (e.g., Masanes and Müller, 2011) to reconstruct complex quantum theory, 3+1-dimensional Lorentzian spacetime, the linear form of Einstein’s gravity, and the Standard Model charges of one generation, each result graded as derived, conditional, prediction, reading, or open. Daw concedes that a physicist may adopt every result while declining the ground, and that no laboratory test separates UCF from the same physics without it. Registered consciousness-side predictions include experience persisting under no-report measures when prefrontal metacognitive markers are abolished, valence tracking upkeep signals named in advance, and no mind-caused collapse, while valence in a system maintained from outside would refute the location rule; cosmological predictions include slightly open space, dark energy with w = −1 exactly, and a scalar spectral index between 0.9674 and 0.9687, with current tensions reported.
References
Bekkers, E. J., and Ciaunica, A. (2026). Unplugging a seemingly sentient machine is the rational choice: A metaphysical perspective. arXiv:2601.21016.
Daw, S. (2026). The Universal Consciousness Framework: A consciousness-first hypothesis, the physics that follows from it, and its registered tests (Master document, version 24, 19 November 2026). Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24356736
Masanes, Ll., and Müller, M. P. (2011). A derivation of quantum theory from physical requirements. New Journal of Physics, 13, 063001.
NOTE: Daw's calculation scripts behind his Universal Consciousness Framework are here:
Scripts: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24388196
Master: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24356736
Guevara-Calderón’s Perception Mechanism Theory
Independent researcher José Tomás Guevara Calderón’s Perception Mechanism Theory (PMT) proposes that consciousness is something fundamental and undifferentiated—termed Universal Consciousness—and by treating Universal Consciousness not as a substrate but as the primordial possibility from which experience can be rendered, PMT reframes the hard problem as a question of rendering architecture rather than metaphysical identity.
Thus, PMT offers a mechanistic account of how awareness generates the world as experienced, such that the felt qualities of experience are not generated by the brain but selected, shaped, and expressed through it. PMT’s unique contribution is the distinction between consciousness as substrate and the processes that transform this substrate into perceptual, cognitive, and narrative experience. The multi-layer "RA/PM" architecture comprises four functional layers. RA4 is the non‑symbolic possibility space of consciousness, not spatial or temporal, analogous to a ground state of awareness. RA3 is a boundary membrane or transition layer where constraints, quantum‑classical effects, and curvature dynamics shape the possible forms of experience. RA2 is the symbolic layer, generating cognition, self‑models, language, and conceptual structures. RA1 is the rendered layer: the stable, coherent world of sensory experience.
The Perception Mechanism (PM) selects, stabilizes, and actualizes experience by filtering information from these layers. PM functions as a selection‑and‑actualization operator rather than a representational system, explaining why conscious experience is unified, coherent, and structured despite the heterogeneity of neural and cognitive processes.
PMT clarifies the partial insights of existing theories by locating them within the rendering pipeline and mapping them to the RA layers for accuracy and balance. Materialist and functionalist theories describe RA1 and RA2 outputs; higher‑order and global workspace theories describe RA2 coordination; quantum theories describe RA3 boundary behavior; panpsychist and idealist theories intuit RA4 but lack mechanistic articulation. PMT provides the architectural mechanism linking these fragments into a coherent whole.
By treating consciousness as substrate and experience as rendered output, PMT reframes the hard problem as a question of rendering architecture rather than metaphysical identity. Thus, by shifting the explanatory space from ontology to mechanism, this approach offers a unifying framework that may help explain both the fragmentation of existing theories and the stability of conscious experience.
Reference
Guevara, J.T. (2025). Twelve Theories of Consciousness — and How GTC/PMT Completes the Picture. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17082952 (doi.org in Bing)
Steinman and Parker’s Direct Light
Independent researchers S. L. Steinman and L. P. Parker propose that phenomenal consciousness is not produced within time but is a timeless, omnipresent sentience that progressively localizes into finite experiencers, beginning with the origin of life, by means of “Direct Light,” an atemporal, zero-latency informational substrate that subsists beneath the spacetime manifold rather than propagating through it (Steinman and Parker, 2026). Time is the principal mechanism of localization: it imposes sequence, locality, and linear causation, generating the experience of a distinct subject within a temporal flow. The authors offer the framework as an ontological and interpretive reframing of the hard problem, quantum measurement, free will in a block universe, and reported precognition, claiming compatibility with established physics while stating that it is not an empirical hypothesis falsifiable “in the usual sense.”
Direct Light is characterized largely by negation (non-waveform, non-energetic, unconstrained by the speed of light) as the expressive field of a single eternal sentience, with spacetime and matter as its modulations; the authors draw analogies to holographic duality and ER=EPR. All life possesses some sentience. Organisms are “wells” of individuated awareness whose coupling to the field is immediate but gradual in fullness, deepening with neurocognitive organization and maturity, so the brain governs the depth of incorporation rather than generating experience. The resulting first-person “I” is a thread that remains connected to the whole: localization is perspectival, not ontological severance. Felt temporal flow, the sense of an isolated subject facing an external world, and the linear ordering of cause and effect arise because the localized thread apprehends the static block universe through a narrow temporal aperture.
The explanatory question is thereby inverted, from how matter produces experience to how an already-minded substrate localizes into temporal perspectives. In states of reduced filtering, such as dreams, meditation, and flow, the temporal “veil” may thin, permitting non-dual experience and precognition, construed as atemporal access to structure already present in the block rather than as retrocausation. In quantum measurement, experiencing is the context in which possibilities actualize; collapse is perspectival, extending Rovelli’s relational interpretation by supplying a minded relational ground. The authors distinguish the view from Kastrup’s analytic idealism by replacing dissociation with zero-latency connective localization, and from Chalmers’s naturalistic dualism by placing sentience prior to time. Its proposed test is phenomenological coherence: whether it renders non-dual experience, precognitive reports, and the observer’s role in measurement more intelligible than time-bound alternatives.
Reference
Steinman, S. L., and Parker, L. P. (2026). Direct Light: Consciousness as an atemporal relational substrate. Manuscript dated 24 March 2026, Toronto.
Hawkins's Map of Consciousness
Psychiatrist and spiritual teacher David Hawkins claims human consciousness comes arrayed with 17 levels and associated “energy fields,” with the “frequency” or “vibration” of energy increasing with each rise in level, along with corresponding implications for emotional tone, view of God, and view of life. Consciousness is pervasive, connecting to God via “devotional nonduality” and enabling, at its higher levels, a beneficial and healing effect on the world. Hawkins says his scientific framework elucidates the spiritual levels delineated by saints, sages, and mystics, with highest levels representing Self-realization, the void, nothingness vs. allness, full enlightenment, and divine realization[2] (Hawkins, 2014, n.d.).
Footnotes
[1]. Readers of Landscape of Consciousness (along with viewers of Closer To Truth) come from ∼190 countries. The passion to explore ultimate questions of consciousness (along with ultimate questions of cosmos, life, and meaning) brings together people from diverse countries, regions, religions, races, ethnicities, genders, ages, educational levels, income levels, and social classes. The only thing we all have in common is the pursuit of these ultimate questions: expressing wonder and awe, and being willing to hear diverse views. But this “only thing” is a “big thing.” We all face the mysteries of cosmic existence and human sentience—the human condition, aspiration, and spirit that unify us all.
[2]. From low to high, Hawkins's 17 levels of consciousness: shame, guilt, apathy, grief, fear, desire, anger, pride, courage, neutrality, willingness, acceptance, reason, love, joy, peace, enlightenment (Hawkins, 2014). I should note that while Hawkins has his acolytes—one of whom implored me to include him on the Landscape—others call him a plagiarist and a charlatan.
Tools
Categories
References
Footnotes
1.
Closer To Truth viewers come from ∼190 countries. The passion to explore ultimate questions of cosmos, consciousness, and meaning brings together diverse countries, regions, religions, races, ethnicities, genders, ages, educational levels, income levels, and social classes. The only thing we all have in common is the pursuit of these ultimate questions: expressing wonder and awe, willing to hear diverse views. But this “only thing” is a “big thing.” We all face the mysteries of cosmic existence and human sentience—the human condition, aspiration and spirit that unify us all.
2.
From low to high, Hawkins's 17 levels of consciousness: shame, guilt, apathy, grief, fear, desire, anger, pride, courage, neutrality, willingness, acceptance, reason, love, joy, peace, enlightenment (Hawkins, 2014). I should note that while Hawkins has his acolytes—one of whom implored me to include him on the Landscape—others call him a plagiarist and a charlatan.